| SUPREME COURT OF TENNESSEE | ||||
| SUPREME COURT DISCRETIONARY APPEALS | ||||
| Grants & Denials LIST | ||||
| Monday, June 27,2005 | ||||
| GRANTS | ||||
| STYLE/APPEAL NUMBER | COUNTY | APPELLATE | NATURE | ACTION |
| TRIAL JUDGE | JUDGE | OF | ||
| TRIAL COURT NO. | JUDGMENT | APPEAL | ||
| Nashville | ||||
| Paul Dennis Reid, Jr. v. State of | Davidson Criminal | Wedemeyer, J | Rule 9 | Granted - Application of Paul Dennis |
| Tennessee | Cheryl Blackburn | Welles, J | Reid, Jr. | |
| M2005 - 00260-SC-S09-PC | 97-C-1834 | Smith, J | ||
| Denied -Rule 9 | ||||
| State of Tennessee v. John C. Walker, III | Putnam Criminal | Hayes, J | Rule 11 | Granted - Application of the State of |
| M2003-01732-SC-R11-CD | Lillie Ann Sells | Affirmed | Tennessee. Granted and Remanded to | |
| 02-0306 | the Court of Criminal Appeals for | |||
| reconsideration in light of State v. | ||||
| Gomez and Londono. | ||||
| * This was filed 6/20/05* | ||||
| Knoxville | ||||
| Jackson | ||||
| State of Tennessee v. Larrie Maclin | Shelby Criminal | Wedemeyer, J | Rule 11 | Granted - Application of Larrie Maclin |
| W2003-03123-SC-R11-CD | Joseph B. Dailey | Smith, J | ||
| 03-00140 | McLin, J | |||
| Affirmed in | ||||
| Part, Reversed | * This case is consolidated for Purposes | |||
| in Part, and | of Oral Argument with State v. Michael | |||
| Remanded | Lebron Anderson* | |||
| State of Tennessee v. Jessica Trotter and | Shelby Criminal | Smith, J | Rule 11 | Granted - Application of the State of |
| Andrew Sheriff | Arthur T. Bennett | Reversed and | Tennessee | |
| W2004-00656-SC-R11-CD | 03-02844 | Remanded | ||
| DENIALS | ||||
| STYLE/APPEAL NUMBER | COUNTY | APPELLATE | NATURE | ACTION |
| TRIAL JUDGE | JUDGE | OF | ||
| TRIAL COURT NO. | JUDGMENT | APPEAL | ||
| Nashville | ||||
| Tezozomoc “Ted” Alcantar, et al. v. | Davidson Circuit | Clement, J | Rule 11 | Denied - Application of Tezozomoc |
| Haulers Insurance Company | Carol Soloman | Affirmed and | “Ted” Alcantar and Judy Alcantar. | |
| M2003-01004-SC-R11-CV | 01C-2237 | Remanded | ||
| ** Motions to consider post-judgment | ||||
| facts also denied ** | ||||
| Michael Blackburn v. State of Tennessee | Franklin Circuit | Wedemeyer, J | Rule 11 | Denied - Application of Michael |
| M2003-2549-SC-R11-PC | J. Curtis Smith | Affirmed | Blackburn | |
| 11223-B | ||||
| Columbia Gulf Transmission Company | Williamson Circuit | Per Curiam | Rule 11 | Denied - Application of the Governors |
| v. The Governors Club Property Owners | Russ Heldman | Denied - Rule | Club Property Owners Association, et al. | |
| Association, et al. | 4660 | 7 | ||
| M2005-01193-SC-R11-CV | ||||
| Earl David Crawford v. State of | Davidson Criminal | Welles, J | Rule 11 | Denied - Application of Earl David |
| Tennessee | J. Randall Wyatt, Jr. | Affirmed | Crawford | |
| M2004-02440-SC-R11-HC | 3546 | |||
| Custom Land Development, Inc. v. | Robertson Chancery | Kirby, J | Rule 11 | Denied - Application of Custom Land |
| Town of Coopertown and Coopertown | Ross H. Hicks | Affirmed | Development, Inc. | |
| Board of zoning Appeals | 17206 | |||
| M2003-02107-SC-R11-CV | ||||
| Richard A. Emmitt v. State of Tennessee | Davidson Criminal | Glenn, J | Rule 11 | Denied - Application of Richard A. |
| M2004-00564-SC-R11-PC | Steve R. Dozier | Affirmed | Emmitt | |
| 84-W-91 | ||||
| Perry Franks v. State of Tenessee | Wayne Circuit | Welles, J | Rule 11 | Denied - Application of Perry Franks |
| M2004-00554-SC-R11-PC | Jim T. Hamilton | Affirmed | ||
| 13156 | ||||
| Helen J. Hollis, individually and as | Davidson Circuit | Per Curiam | Rule 11 | Denied - Application of Helen J. Hollis |
| surviving spouse of Billy Coy Hollis | Walter C. Kurtz | Denied - Rule | ||
| deceased v. HCA Health Services of | 99C-845 | 9 | ||
| Tennessee, Inc., d/b/a Summit Medical | ||||
| Center | ||||
| M2005-00539-SC-S09-CV | ||||
| Shemain Johnson v. State of Tennessee | Davidson Criminal | Hayes, J | Rule 11 | Denied - Application of Shemain |
| M2003-03084-SC-R11-PC | Cheryl Blackburn | Affirmed | Johnson | |
| 2001-C-1740-, 2001-B-1165 | ||||
| Judy Kesterson v. Bruce Varner | Williamson Chancery | Cain, J | Rule 11 | Denied - Application of Bruce Varner |
| M2003-00743-SC-R11-CV | Russ Heldman | Affirmed and | ||
| II-26072 | Remanded | * Plaintiff’s Motion to dismiss also | ||
| denied* | ||||
| State of Tennessee v. Margie Jeanette | Warren County | Glenn, J | Rule 11 | Denied - Application of Margie Jeanette |
| Farley | James L. Weatherford | Affirmed and | Farley | |
| M2003-02826-SC-R11-CD | F-8248 | Remanded For | ||
| Entry of | ||||
| Corrected | ||||
| Judgments | ||||
| State of Tennessee v. James Harvey | Bedford Circuit | Welles, J | Rule 11 | Denied - Application of James Harvey |
| Farrar, Jr. | Lee Russell | Affirmed as | Farrar, Jr. | |
| M2003-02271-SC-R11-CD | 15205 | Modified | ||
| ** The opinion of the Court of Criminal | ||||
| Appeals is designated “Not for Citation” | ||||
| in accordance with Supreme Court Rule | ||||
| 4, § F.** | ||||
| State of Tennessee v. Vick R. Nichols, | Lewis Circuit | Hayes, J | Rule 11 | Denied - Application of Vick R. |
| Jr. | Robert E. Lee Davies | Dismissed | Nichols, Jr. | |
| M2003-2001-SC-R11-CD | 6393 | |||
| State of Tennessee v. Calvin Louis Hill | Marshall Circuit | Wedemeyer, J | Rule 11 | Denied - Application of Calvin Louis |
| M2004-00597-SC-R11-CD | Charles Lee | Affirmed | Hill | |
| 15728 | ||||
| ** The opinion of the Court of Criminal | ||||
| Appeals is designated “Not for Citation” | ||||
| in accordance with Supreme Court Rule | ||||
| 4, § F.** | ||||
| State of Tennessee v. James Wayne | Davidson Criminal | Ogle, J | Rule 11 | Denied - Application of James Wayne |
| Kimbrough | Steve R. Dozier | Affirmed | Kimbrough | |
| M2003-00719-SC-R11-CD | 2001-D-2439 | |||
| State of Tennessee v. Michael Wayne | Cannon Circuit | Williams, J | Rule 11 | Denied - Application of Michael Wayne |
| Smithson | J.S. Daniel | Affirmed | Smithson | |
| M2004-01411-SC-R11-CD | F01-05 | |||
| State of Tennessee v. Colia Louis | Bedford Circuit | Woodall, J | Rule 11 | Denied - Application of Colia Louis |
| Streeter | Charles Lee | Affirmed | Streeter | |
| M2004-00543-SC-R11-CD | 15358 | |||
| State of Tennessee v. David Sever | White Criminal | Glenn, J | Rule 11 | Denied - Application of David Sever |
| Watkins | Leon Burns, Jr. | Affirmed | Watkins | |
| M2003-01488-SC-R11-CD | CR1172 | |||
| State of Tennessee v. Robert Wilson | Marion Circuit | Wade, J | Rule 11 | Denied - Application of Robert Wilson |
| M2004-00110-SC-R11-CD | James C. Smith | Affirmed as | ||
| 5935 | Modified | ** The opinion of the Court of Criminal | ||
| Appeals is designated “Not for Citation” | ||||
| in accordance with Supreme Court Rule | ||||
| 4, § F.** | ||||
| James A. Uhles v. State of Tennessee | Davidson Criminal | Welles, J | Rule 11 | Denied - Application f James A. Uhles |
| M2004-2002-SC-R11-HC | Robert L. Jones | Affirmed - | ||
| 97-B-1232 | Rule 20 | |||
| Donald Wallace v. State of Tennessee | Stewart Circuit | Witt, J | Rule 11 | Denied - Application of Donald Wallace |
| M2004-2976-SC-R11-PC | Robert E. Burch | Affirmed | ||
| 4-769-CR-96 | ||||
| John Ralph Wood v. Judith A. (Grande) | Smith Circuit | Cottrell, J | Rule 11 | Denied - Application of John Ralph |
| Wood | Clara W. Byrd | Affirmed as | Wood | |
| M2003-00193-SC-R11-CV | 4996 | Modified and | ||
| Remanded | *Motion to Consider Post-Judgment | |||
| Facts, Overruled.* | ||||
| Fred H. Wright, Ph.D. v. Tennessee | Davidson Chancery | Highers, J | Rule 11 | Denied - Application of Fred H. Wright, |
| Board of Examiners in Psychology | Irvin H. Kilcrease, Jr. | Affirmed | Ph.D. | |
| M2003-01654-SC-R11-CV | 02-3172-I | |||
| Knoxville | ||||
| Richard & Faye Anderson, et al. v. | Unicoi Circuit | Peoples, J | Rule 11 | Denied - Application of Richard & Faye |
| American Limestone Company, Inc., et | Thomas J. Seeley, Jr. | Affirmed | Anderson | |
| al. | 6230 | |||
| E2003-01979-SC-R11-CV | ||||
| Jerry Biggs v. Reinsman Equestrian | Bradley Chancery | Franks, J | Rule 11 | Denied - Application of Reinsman |
| Products, Inc. | Jerri Bryant | Equestrian Products, Inc. | ||
| E2004-00172-SC-R11-CV | 00-369 | |||
| Samuel Dwayne Davis v. State of | Knox Criminal | Witt, J | Rule 11 | Denied - Application of Samuel Dwayne |
| Tennessee | Richard Baumgartner | Wade, J | Davis | |
| E2004-01943-SC-R11-CO | 33857 & 65155 | Ogle, J | ||
| Dismissed | ||||
| Diagnostic Center and Diagnostic | Hamilton Circuit | Susano, J | Rule 10 | Denied - Application of Steven B. |
| Associates of Chattanooga v. | Samuel H. Payne | Swiney, J | Stubblefield, M.D., Steven B. | |
| Stubblefield, M.D., Steven B. | 04-C-851 | Lee, J | Stubblefield, M.D., P.C., and Steven B. | |
| Stubblefield, M.D., P.C. and Steven B. | Denied- Rule | Stubblefield Trust | ||
| Stufflefield Trust | 10 | |||
| E2005-00407-SC-S10-CV | ||||
| Clyde M. Fuller v. Samuel & Patty | Hamilton Circuit | Lee, J | Rule 11 | Denied - Application of Samuel & Patty |
| Evans | Jackie Schulten | Affirmed | Evans | |
| E2004-00801-SC-R11-CV | 98-C-2355 | |||
| Luther E. Fowler v. State of Tenessee | Johnson Circuit | Witt, J | Rule 11 | Denied - Application of Luther E. |
| E2004-01346-SC-R11-HC | Robert E. Cupp | Affirmed | Flowers | |
| 4331 | ||||
| Effie L. Hayes v. Opal M. Shaw | Hamilton Circuit | Swiney, J | Denied - Petition captioned “Mandate | |
| E2004-01851-SC-R11-CV | Jackie Schulten | Affirmed and | and Stay Pending Further Appeal, Stay | |
| 03-C-1193 | Remanded | According to State Law.” | ||
| State of Tennessee v. Faron Pierce | Knox Criminal | Williams, J | Rule 11 | Denied - Application of Faron Pierce |
| E2001-00437-SC-R11-CD | Richard Baumgartner | Affirmed | ||
| 67174B | ||||
| Jackson | ||||
| Stanley Adams v. David Mills | Lauderdale Circuit | Glenn, J | Rule 11 | Denied - Application of Stanley Adams |
| W2004-00758-SC-R11-HC | Joe H. Walker | Affirmed - | ||
| 5832 | Rule 20 | |||
| Duke Bowers Clement v. Janet Leigh | Shelby Circuit | Crawford, J | Rule 11 | Denied - Application of Duke Bowers |
| Traylor Clement | George H. Brown | Affirmed in | Clement. | |
| W2003-02388-SC-R11-CV | CT-000776-01 | Part, Modified | ||
| in Part and | ||||
| Remanded | ||||
| Kenyatta Darden, a Minor, By and | Shelby Circuit | Farmer, J | Rule 10 | Denied - Application of Dr. Frank Ling, |
| Through his mother and next friend, | George H. Brown, Jr. | Highers, J | Dr. Baha Sibai, and UT Medical Group, | |
| Lashonda Jarrett v. UT Medical Group, | CT-000273-03 | Denied | Inc. | |
| Inc., Baha Sibai, M.D., Frank Ling, | ||||
| M.D., and Shelby County Health Care | ||||
| Corporation, D/B/A The Regional | ||||
| Medical Center at Memphis | ||||
| W2005-00423-SC-S10-CV | ||||
| Carl Johnson v. State of Tennessee | Shelby Criminal | Ogle, J | Rule 11 | Denied - Application of Carl Johnson |
| W2003-02760-SC-R11-PC | Joseph B. Dailey | Reversed and | ||
| P-26265 | Remanded | |||
| Cynthia Lynn Alston Houston Johnston | Shelby Circuit | Kirby, J | Rule 11 | Denied - Application of Walter Rex |
| v. Walter Rex Houston | Robert L. Childers | Affirmed | Houston | |
| W2004-02915-SC-R11-CV | 131541 | |||
| Albert Frank Kelly v. State of Tennessee | Shelby Criminal | Williams, J | Rule 11 | Denied - Application of Albert Frank |
| W2004-01580-SC-R11-PC | Bernie Weinman | Affirmed | Kelly | |
| P-26794 | ||||
| Coleen L. Powers; James G. Blodgett, | Shelby Circuit | Farmer, J | Rule 10 | Denied - Application of Coleen L. |
| Jr., et al. v. Milton H. Hamilton, Jr; | Karen R. Williams | Highers, J | Powers, et al. | |
| Pollution Control Ind., et al | CT-003265-04 | Denied | ||
| W2005-00463-SC-R10-CV | ||||
| State of Tennessee v. Perry Barnum | Shelby Criminal | Williams, J | Rule 11 | Denied - Application of Perry Barnum |
| W2004-01353-SC-R11-CD | James C. Beasley, Jr. | Affirmed | ||
| 02-05705 | ||||
| State of Tennessee v. Cornelius Boales | Henderson County | Hayes, J | Rule 11 | Denied - Application of Cornelius |
| W2003-02724-SC-R11-CD | Donald H. Allen | Affirmed in | Boales | |
| 03005-2 | Part; Sent. | |||
| Modified | ** The opinion of the Court of Criminal | |||
| Appeals is designated “Not for Citation” | ||||
| in accordance with Supreme Court Rule | ||||
| 4, § F.** | ||||
| State of Tennessee v. Patrick Harris | Shelby Criminal | Witt, J | Rule 11 | Denied - Application of Patrick Harris |
| W2004-00469-SC-R11-CD | Bernie Weinman | Affirmed | ||
| 03-01420 | ||||
| State of Tennessee v. Steve Skinner | Shelby Criminal | Mclin, J | Rule 11 | Denied - Application of Steve Skinner |
| W2003-00887-SC-R11-CD | Joseph B. Dailey | Affirmed | ||
| 00-05699, 00-05700 | ||||
| Kenneth B. White v. State of Tennessee | Shelby Criminal | Williams, J | Rule 11 | Denied - Application of Kenneth B. |
| W2004-00653-SC-R11-CO | Joseph B. Dailey | Affirmed | White | |
| P-27672 | ||||